Home Blog

The Golden Age of Muslim Spain: Contributions to Science, Medicine, and Philosophy

0

Abstract

This study examines the period between the eighth and the fifteenth centuries, known as the Golden Age of Muslim Spain (Al-Andalus). It demonstrates how remarkable the intellectual and cultural accomplishments of this era were. The paper examines the important advances in philosophy, science, and medicine made by Muslim Spain, highlighting the ways in which these discoveries impacted later European trends, such as the Renaissance. The scientific contributions include chemistry, astronomy, mathematics, and agriculture; the medical advancements include pharmacology, surgery, and the classification of diseases. Al-Andalus’s lasting impact as a crucial hub for the diffusion and synthesis of knowledge is highlighted by this study.

Introduction

This study examines how, while under Muslim control, Al-Andalus developed into one of the world’s most developed cultures, acting as a lighthouse of advancement and knowledge. Diverse cultures, such as Arab, Berber, Jewish, and Christian traditions, came together to create a setting where academics from various backgrounds could work together and advance human knowledge across a range of fields. Classical Greek, Roman, and Persian knowledge was preserved and advanced through the construction of large libraries, universities, and translation centers in places like Córdoba, Toledo, and Granada. This knowledge later impacted the European Renaissance. Moreover, Al-Andalus witnessed revolutionary breakthroughs in science, including chemistry, astronomy, mathematics, and agriculture. By improving scientific procedures and creating advanced tools like the astrolabe, scholars expanded on previously acquired knowledge from Greek and Indian sources. Later advances in Europe relied heavily on the algebraic principles and numerical methods that mathematicians introduced. While agricultural specialists transformed irrigation methods and recorded several plant species that improved food production, chemists in Al-Andalus developed the study of substances and their qualities, establishing the groundwork for modern chemistry. On the other hand, Muslim Spanish medicine advanced to previously unheard-of levels as researchers focused on clinical practice, empirical observation, and innovative surgery. Al-Zahrawi, regarded as the father of modern surgery, was one of the pioneers who created a vast array of surgical tools and methods that were used for decades. Ibn Zuhr improved disease detection and therapy by making important contributions to experimental medicine and pathology. Early pharmacopoeias that were later adopted in Europe were based on the documentation of medicinal plants and their applications brought about by advances in pharmacology. Hospitals and other medical facilities grew, offering organized instruction and treatment, and establishing norms that influenced subsequent Western medical procedures.
The legacy of Muslim Spain’s intellectual achievements is evident in the profound impact it had on European learning and the eventual emergence of the Renaissance. The transmission of knowledge through translation movements in Toledo and elsewhere ensured that the discoveries and philosophical insights of Al-Andalus were preserved and disseminated throughout Europe. This period demonstrated how cultural and intellectual exchange could drive human progress, and its contributions continue to be acknowledged in modern science, medicine, and philosophy. The Golden Age of Muslim Spain remains a testament to the power of knowledge and collaboration in shaping civilizations, serving as an enduring example of how diverse traditions can come together to foster remarkable advancements in human thought and understanding.

Literature review

This literature review highlights important individuals, their discoveries, and the wider influence on later European developments as it examines diverse scholarly viewpoints on Al-Andalus’ contributions to science, medicine, and philosophy.

Science in Al-Andalus

Research on Muslim Spain’s scientific achievements frequently emphasizes the preservation and advancement of Indian, Persian, and Greek knowledge. George Saliba contends that Al-Andalus’ scientific advancements, especially in the domains of mathematics and astronomy, had a significant influence on European intellectual movements. As his research shows, Andalusian scholars helped establish algebra and trigonometry and improved astronomy equipment like the astrolabe. In a same vein, Thomas Glick highlights the progress made in agricultural science, describing how Muslim Spain transformed European agronomy through the introduction of novel irrigation systems and crop production methods.
The development of medicine in Al-Andalus has been a major area of study, and important personalities like Al-Zahrawi and Ibn Zuhr have been acknowledged for their contributions. Al-Zahrawi’s surgical encyclopedia, Al-Tasrif, had a centuries-long impact on European medical education, as Ehsan Masood emphasizes. According to Manfred Ullmann, Ibn Zuhr’s contributions to experimental medicine and pathology laid the groundwork for clinical medicine during the Middle Ages. By bridging the gap between classical knowledge and Renaissance medical achievements, these medical texts—which were translated into Latin—became indispensable resources in European colleges.

Philosophy and Intellectual Exchange

Western thought was significantly influenced by Muslim Spain’s philosophical contributions. Ibn Rushd’s (Averroes) commentary on Aristotle not only maintained Greek philosophy but also brought rationalist ideas back to Europe, as Majid Fakhry examines. Richard C. Taylor delves deeper into the ways that Ibn Rushd’s writings impacted Scholastic philosophers like Thomas Aquinas, easing the intellectual shift into the Renaissance. The Jewish-Muslim philosophical exchanges in Al-Andalus are also covered by Sarah Stroumsa , with special attention to Maimonides, whose fusion of religious thought and Aristotelian philosophy had a long-lasting impact on both Islamic and Christian traditions.
Transmission of Knowledge and the European Renaissance
The contribution of Al-Andalus to the dissemination of knowledge in Europe has been studied by numerous academics. According to Charles Burnett , the translation effort in Toledo played a significant role in the introduction of Arabic intellectual and scientific writings into Latin Europe. European scholars were able to acquire a multitude of knowledge that influenced the intellectual climate of the High Middle Ages and the Renaissance thanks to the work of translators like Gerard of Cremona.
Research Methodology
In this research paper the qualitative research methodology is being used.
Golden Age of Muslim Spain
Arabic became more widely spoken among his non-Muslim people, particularly in the towns, under ‘Abd al-Rahman II of Córdoba, which resulted in a great flourishing of intellectual activity of all kinds and marked the beginning of Islamic culture in Spain to develop in earnest. Because the ruler’s preferences and tastes set the tone for society in a courtly society, ‘Abd al-Rahman II was adamant about demonstrating to the world that his court was on par with the caliphs’ court in Baghdad. He had a strong interest in both religious and secular sciences.
To this end, therefore, he actively recruited scholars by offering handsome inducements to overcome their initial reluctance to live in what many in the lands of the East considered the provinces. As a result, many scholars, poets, philosophers, historians and musicians migrated to Al-Andalus, and established the basis of the intellectual tradition and educational system, which made Spain so outstanding for the next 400 years.
One of these early intellectuals was ‘Abbas ibn Firnas, who would have been a “Renaissance man” if he had lived in the Florence of the Medici. He passed away in the year 888. Not one to confine himself to a single subject of study, he initially came to Córdoba to teach music, which was then a branch of mathematical theory. However, he quickly developed an interest in flight mechanics. He built two wings out of feathers in a wooden frame and tried to fly; he was about 600 years before Leonardo da Vinci.
Muslims Contribution in Science, Medicine and Philosophy
In addition to astronomy (al-Bitruji, al-Zarqali, ibn Aflah, al-Majriti), medicine (Ibn Zuhr, Az-Zahrawi), philosophy (ibn Bajja, Ibn Tofail, Ibn Rushd), lexicography, history, geography (al-Bekri), and botany (Ibn Baitar), Islamic Spain produced distinguished scientists in a variety of other subjects. These topics primarily piqued the interest of Andalusian scholars due of their religious significance. To calculate inheritance, town distances, and commodity pricing, mathematics was required. Seasons, the time of the mandated prayers, and the location of the Kaaba from anywhere in the world had to be determined by astronomy. The preservation of health and spiritual purity required medicine. Islamic Spain possessed a number of observatories. Ibn Bajja had his own observatory, Jabir ibn Aflah utilized the minaret of the Grand Mosque of Seville (La Giralda) as an observatory, and Zarqali worked on his Toledan Tables in Toledo. After 25 years of intricate planning and building, Seville’s Giralda Tower was finished in 1198. Its base is 300 square feet, and it stands 300 feet high. One can reach the summit on the back of a horse because there are ramps instead of stairs. Seven planets were represented by its seven rooms. It was then transformed into a belfry and continues to rule the city. This tower, which was packed with tourists, was viewed by the author in August 1999. Knowledge was not as divided a millennium ago as it is now; a mathematician could be both a philosopher and a musician, and a poet could be both a doctor and a philosopher. Astronomy, mathematics, and physics were all tightly related fields; if a scholar wrote about one, he also wrote about the others. As the following list will demonstrate, some scientists conducted their research in several domains.
Abbas ibn Firnas:
He served as the emirs Muhammad I and Abdur Rahman II’s astrologer and poet laureate. His capacity to create novel inventions made him well-known. He brought the Sindhind tables from Baghdad, which had a significant impact on the advancement of European astronomy. He was the first person in history to attempt flying scientifically. A set of feathers with wings made up his flying apparatus, which allowed him to soar far. Because his outfit lacked a tail, he injured himself as he got off. In Spain, he brought oriental music. He is credited with discovering rock crystal and built an armillary sphere, a clock, and a planetarium in his house. In Spain, he brought the method of crystal cutting.

Ibn Abd Rabbihi:


The first literary history of Islamic Spain is found in his book Aqd al-Farid, also known as The Unique Necklace. Saeed Abd Rabbihi, his nephew, was a poet and physician
Rabi ibn Zaid al-Usquf
He served as the emir al-Hakam II’s bishop of Cordoba. He mostly used Arabic in his writing. He donated a calendar known as Kitab al-Anwa to Caliph al-Hakam II and wrote a number of astrological treatises.
Joseph the Wise :
 He wrote a treatise on multiplication and division.
Hasday ibn Shaprut:
 He thrived at the courts of al-Hakam II and Abdur Rahman III. He served as both of these emirs’ court physician. He was a major supporter of science and translated Greek classics into Arabic. He found al-Farooq (the best), a cure-all. Hasday was one of five translators (five Spanish and one Greek-speaking Arab) who helped the Greek monk Nicholas translate the old manuscript of Dioscorides’ Materia Medica, which was a gift from the Greek emperor Constantinus VII to Caliph Abdur Rahman III. He described Islamic Spain in a letter to the King of Khazzars.

Yahya ibn Ishaq:


 He worked at Emir Abdur Rahman III’s court as a vizier and doctor (912-961). He wrote five volumes of medical literature.
Maslama ibn Ahmad al-Majriti  
Although he was born in Majrit (Madrid), he thrived in Cordoba, where he founded a school that later students like Ibn Khaldun and az-Zahrawi took classes. Al-Andalus’s first mathematician and astronomer was him. He wrote a treatise on the astrolabe, a commentary on Ptolemy’s Planisphere, a book on commercial arithmetic al-Muamilat, a book on the generations of animals, and a correction and revision of Khawarizmi’s planetary tables (ZIJ). Al-Karmani (d.1066), ibn Samh, and ibn Saffar were among his well-known followers.
He spoke about the sensual potential of friendly numbers. Ghiyataul Hakim (Aim of the Wise) and Rutabatul Hakim (Sage’s Step) are two of his chemical writings. King Alfonso the Wise ordered the first book to be translated into Latin in 1252 under the title Picatrix. It continued to be the cornerstone of European chemistry literature for many years.

Ibn al-Jazzar : ( Latin Algizar)


In Qairwan, Tunis, he thrived. His well-known work, Zad al-Musafir (Travelers Provisions), was translated into Greek, Hebrew, and Latin by Constantine Africanus. He was a renowned physician. In it, measles and smallpox are described in astonishing detail. He also wrote about the reasons behind Egypt’s plague. In 1230, a Latin translation of his book Kitab Itimad fee Adwiya al-Mufrada (Reliable & Simple Drugs) was produced.
Ibn al -Qutiyya :
Despite being born in Seville, he settled in Cordoba. A renowned historian and grammarian, he was. Tarikh al-Andalus (History of Islamic Spain) covers the Muslim conquest up to 893, whereas Tarikh al-Iftah al-Andalus covers the Muslim conquest up to Emir Abdur Rahman III’s rule. His Kitab al-Tasrif al-Afaal, the first treatise ever written on the subject, dealt with the conjugations of Arabic verbs.

Menaham ben Saruq:


 He was a renowned scholar of philology. His primary contribution is the first comprehensive lexicon of biblical language. It included philological information as well as grammatical comments.

Abu Zakariya Yahya ibn Daud: (Avendeath) 


Although he was born in Toledo, he thrived in Cordoba. He is credited with founding scientific Hebrew grammar. Arabic grammar served as the foundation for his writing in that language. Even now, the technical terminology used in Hebrew grammar are translated from their Arabic equivalents. Only Gerard was better than him at translations. Numerous astronomical works by Abu Mashar, Sabit ibn Qurra, Meshallah, and al-Farghani were translated by him. His contemporaries, the Turkish author al-Farabi, translated his works “On the Origin of the Sciences” and “On the Divisions of Philosophy.” Hecollaborated with Gundisalvi in various translations, for instance, he turned Ibn Sena’s On the Soul into Spanish, and Gundisalvi turned it into Latin.

Arib ibn Sad al-Qurtubi: 


 At the court of Al-Hakam II and Emir Abdur Rahman III in Cordoba, he thrived. He was renowned as a doctor and historian. A chronicle of Muslim Africa and Spain was written by him. His other works include a calendar (Kitab al Anwa), obstetrics (Khalq al Janin, the production of embryo 964), gynecology, and the hygiene of expectant mothers and newborns.
Hasan ibn Juljul :
He developed a strong interest in medicine at the age of 14, and this medical historian was born in Cordoba. At the age of 24, he was one of Al Andalus’ top doctors. He wrote a commentary on the names of simple pharmaceuticals included in Dioscorides’ Materia Medica, a treatise on drugs Dioscorides did not mention, such as those found in Spain, a book on antidotes, and a work on doctor errors. He worked as a doctor for Caliph Hisham II. Tarikh al-Atiba wal Hukama (History of Physicians and Wise Men), the first Arabic synopsis of medical history, was written by him and chronicles the doctors and philosophers of his era in Spain. It has 57 biographies, 31 of which are by Oriental authors; the remaining ones are by Spanish and African authors.

 Ibn Rushd: ( Latin Averroes) 


He came from a noble family in Cordoba and was Spain’s best physician and philosopher. He was given the status of a Qazi, second only to the Caliph, in Cordoba and Seville. The Caliph Abu Yakub Yusuf made him his personal doctor. He was one of Ibn Tofail’s friends. He was well-versed in Greek sciences from an early age. His name was The Commentator, and he published 38 commentaries on different Aristotelian texts.
Typically, he composed a lengthy commentary (Sharh), a medium (Talkhis, résumé), and a short (Jami). The University of Paris adopted his writings as required reading. Up until the 17th century, the intellectual movement he founded continued to influence European thought. His writings were frequently translated into Latin and Hebrew in 1230, making Cordoba the Athens of the West. (Page 160, Arab Capital Cities of Islam) Averroism is the school of thought that interprets Aristotle via him. He was Ibn Zuhr’s companion and disciple.
He also wrote about science, medicine, and astronomy. In 1255, Bancosa translated his book Kulliyat fi Tibb (General Rules of Medicine) into Latin (Colliget) in Padua. It was well known (printed editions Vienna 1496, Augsburg 1519, Arabic text with Latin Oxford 1778, French 1861). He explained in this book how the retina actually functions as a photoreceptor, taking in and sending images to the brain.
Additionally, he said that people who have smallpox develop immunity. Anatomy, medications, nutrition, physiology, illness, and its symptoms are all covered in the book. He authored sixteen medical works in all.
His book, Tahaftul Tahafah (Incoherence of Incoherence), was a paragraph-by-paragraph critique of Imam al-Ghazali’s “Tahaftul Filasfa,” outlining his views on the capacity of reason to comprehend the mysteries of the cosmos. In 1328, it was translated into Latin. He finished writing a book on Islamic law in 1188 that covered the distinctions between Muslim schools and the justifications offered by each.
After a serious inquisition, the Ulema proclaimed him a heretic (zendik) for his beliefs in eternity, predestination, and bodily resurrection, which caused him to lose the favor of the Caliph. He was exiled from Seville when his writings were burned in public. He was banished to Lucena, a tiny town close to Cordoba. Al-Mansoor, the son of Caliph Abu Yakub, ordered the burning of all of his writings in 1195, with the exception of his treatises on astronomy, medicine, and mathematics. Yakoob bin Yousuf (1186–1197), the Almohade Caliph of Seville, later overturned the edict, but he did not relish his comeback and passed away in Morocco on December 11, 1198. The Escorial library in Madrid has his Arabic commentary (Jawami) intact. Up to the sixteenth century, his writings had a significant impact on both Jewish and Christian intellectuals. “The great Muslim whose translations and speculations were the seed whose fruit was the reformation of Christendom was almost without influence in Islam,” according to English scholar Burke (History of Spain, Burke, 1894, page 209). He was extensively discussed by the 19th-century French scholar Ernest Renan, and some of his opinions were backed up by William James in Principles of Psychology.

Ibn Maymoon: (Maimonides)


 He was educated by his father and Muslim instructors after being born in Cordoba. He left Spain when he was 13 and settled in Cairo in 1155 after roving over Morocco and Palestine. In Jewish history, he was the most distinguished physician and philosopher. He authored a number of Arabic-language medical and philosophical publications. Friedlander translated his masterpiece, Dalalat al-Hairin, Guide for the Perplexed, into English in 1884. He discusses the unity of God in his significant work Maqala Fee Tawhid. He served as Sultan Salahuddin Ayubi’s personal doctor. He held a number of prominent positions in Cairo, but he never accepted payment; instead, he practiced medicine to support himself.

Ibn al-Arabi:


He studied in al-Andalus and North Africa after being born in Murcia. He made a pilgrimage in 1201, and he lived in Mecca, Baghdad, and Damascus for the remainder of his life. With a massive literary output of 251 books, Mohiyuddin ibnul al-Arabi was the greatest mystical writer of the Middle Ages. He wrote about his encounters with eminent academics and professors in his book Tartib al-Rihlah (The Itinerary of a Journey). A mosque in Damascus houses his tomb. He was known to his supporters as al-Shaykh al-Akbar, or Grand Master.

Ibn Baytar:


 Malaga was his birthplace. During the Middle Ages, he was the best botanist and chemist. He studied botany with great interest and gained knowledge via experimentation and observation. After departing Spain in 1219 to embark on a plant-collecting expedition, he continued his botanical research in Arabia, Syria, and Iraq. One of his pupils was the distinguished historian Ibn abi Usaiba, who wrote a history of 600 doctors. He passed away in Damascus. His collection of basic foods and medicines, al-Jami al-Mufridat al-Adwiya wal-Aghziya (Cairo 1291 AH), is organized alphabetically. He corrected the errors of 150 authors, both Greek and Islamic. Three hundred of the approximately 1400 plants and minerals described were novelties. As late as 1758, this work was published in Latin from Italy. This is a remarkable piece of observation; in fact, it is the best book on botany written in Arabic.
Ibn al-Banna:
His book Talkhis summarizes the lost work of the mathematician al-Hassar from the 12th century, and he wrote a risala (treatise) on the astrolabe called “Safiha Shakaziyya.” He was a native of Granada and taught geometry, astronomy, algebra, and arithmetic in the madrassa in Fez, Morocco. He wrote about 82 works, including an almanac, a treatise on algebra, an introduction to Euclid, and books on astronomy called “Kitab al-Anwa,” “Minhaj,” and an almanac.

Ibn Khaldun:


He was the most renowned Arab historian in history. His family had relocated from Seville, Spain, to Tunis, where he was born. He traveled to Christian Seville on a diplomatic trip while he was living in Granada (1362-1365). Here, he began writing his well-known book Kitab al-Ibar (History of the World), which he finished in 1377 with its Muqaddama (Introduction).
He returned to Tunis to complete this monumental work. In Egypt, he became a professor and administrator at al-Azhar university. In 1387 he performed Hajj and in 1401 he met Mongol conqueror Tamarlene in Damascus. He died in Cairo on 17th March 1406. He is considered to be the founder of the science of sociology.

 Lisanu din ibn al-Khatib:


He was one of the 14th century’s great writers. He wrote almost sixty books on philosophy, geography, history, and medicine. He wrote a very helpful biographical dictionary called “Raqm al-Hulal fi nazm ad-Duwal,” which describes the history of Islam in Spain and is made up of odes and muwashahs (folk songs). He wrote his two-volume history of Granada al-Ihatah fi Tarikh al-Gharnatah from Cairo in 1319. He was known as Zul-wazaratayn, or vizier of the pen and political vizier, in the kingdom of Granada. His two-volume book al-Yusufi was a standard medical text. He was the final scholar in Islamic Spain, and his interest in the sciences waned after his passing. His writings are among the first encyclopedias in the history of letters.

 Abul Hassan al-Qalasadi :



He passed away in Beja, Tunisia, after being born in Basta (now Baza). His contributions to mathematics and arithmetic are what made him most famous. He was the final known Muslim mathematician from Spain. He is credited with writing a number of publications, including one on algebra that is a commentary on ibn Yasmini’s (d. 1204) al-Urjuza al-Yasminiyya, which provided algebraic rules in poetry. One of his mathematical works is a commentary on Ibn al-Banna’s TALKHIS amal al-Hisab. Kashf al-Jilbab an ilm al-Hisan (Unveiling the science of Arithmetic) and al-Tabsira fi ilm al-Hisab (Classification of the science of Arithmetic) are his unique works. For generations, North African schools used these books.

Technology in Islamic Spain 


 During the Middle Ages, technology traveled through Islamic nations from distant China, India, and Persia to Europe. For instance, in the tenth century, paper was introduced to Islamic Spain after initially being produced in Samarcand. Because Al-Andalus was skilled in producing weights and scales (MIZAN), these were shipped to Morocco. France’s textiles, both in terms of style and technique, were entirely influenced by Islamic Spain. The spread of hydraulic devices was accelerated by the scarcity of water. To distribute water throughout the cities, lead pipes were transported from the mountains. Every mansion had running water and fountains because Spanish Muslims adored the water. In 940, Abdur Rahman III built a scientifically planned aqueduct across the Guadalquivir River’s arches (Wadi al-Kabir). After that, pipes carried the water to Cordoba’s waterworks. Muslims brought modern irrigation techniques to agriculture. The increase in olive oil production was so great that the majority of the equipment used were referred to in Arabic by Europeans. Crystal was found at Cordoba’s glass workshops. Malaga, Murcia, Almeria, and Barcelona all had thriving glass industries where glass vessels were blown. The term “Glass of Damascus” described enameled glass in the Syrian style. Beautiful pottery was produced in Valencia (Balnasiyya), Jaen (Jayyan) was famous for its gold and silver mines, Cordoba for its iron and lead, Malaga (Malaka) for its ruby mines, and Toledo (Tolaytla) for its swords. Seville was the hub of silk weaving, and 3000 villages were dedicated to raising silkworms.
The first European paper mills were built in Islamic Spain. Some Muslims went by the surname name al-Waraq, which means “the papermaker.” Flax fibers, or old scrap clothing, were soaked in quicklime, cleaned, mashed, and dried in molds to make paper. Rags for the paper industry were a profession at the one-time meeting. The initial hub of this sector in Spain and Europe was Jativa (Shatiba), which produced the product known as Shatibi. The paper was shipped from Barcelona and Valencia to Sicily in the thirteenth century.
This business in Islamic Spain had a major role in the spreading dissemination of knowledge throughout Europe through mechanical printing. One of Islamic Spain’s greatest gifts to Europe was paper. Through Spain, paper mills made their way to France. The Arabic word rizma, which means bundle, is the source of the English term ream.
Islamic Spain also left a lasting impression on Europe in the textile sector. The port cities of Almeria and Malaga were well-known for their Tiraz (brocade), which is silk fabric embroidered with Arabic letters. The state-sponsored Tiraz industry was operated by skilled weavers who attended a school known as Dar al-Tiraz. Costumes of Caliphs, officials, and military commanders were made from tira cloth. Large amounts of attabi and isfahani fabrics were also manufactured. The silk and cotton cloth known as “attabi” was named for the Baghdadi neighborhood where it first appeared. Under the trade name tabis, it was widely available in European stores. In European marketplaces, Grenadan dress materials were referred to as “Grenadines.” In Spain, tanning techniques developed a variety of soft leathers. Goatskin that had been vegetable-tanned was called Cordoban (Cordwain). In Cuenca and numerous other towns, ivory was crafted. Many cities also created ivory paintings with Arabic lettering. A school of ivory-carvers based in Cordoba produced work in the tenth century that exuded mature expertise. The cylindrical casket created for Caliph al-Hakam II in 964 and on exhibit at the Museo Archeologico in Madrid is one of the surviving examples of their work. Pottery was produced for wealthy households in Portugal, France, and Italy as well as for popes and cardinals. The painted drug jars were centered in Valencia. Italian potters of the 16th century were influenced by the glossy ceramics of Spain.

Conclusion

Science, medicine, and philosophy all made tremendous strides during the Golden Age of Muslim Spain (Al-Andalus), which was a time of great intellectual and cultural accomplishment. Al-Andalus became a center of knowledge in medieval Europe because of the collaboration of Muslim scholars with Jewish and Christian intellectuals to establish a thriving intellectual environment. Scientists like Al-Zarqali improved the astrolabe and impacted European navigation with their revolutionary contributions to astronomy. Under leaders like Al-Muqaddasi, who created trigonometric ideas that subsequently influenced European mathematical philosophy, mathematics flourished. Classical knowledge, which was later reintroduced to Europe during the Renaissance, was preserved and expanded upon by the translation of Greek, Roman, and Persian writings into Arabic.

Gat General Test Schedule 2025

0

The National Testing Service (NTS) plays a crucial role in conducting the Graduate Assessment Test (GAT) in Pakistan. GAT is a standardized test used for admission into various universities and for recruitment purposes by different organizations. As the year 2025 begins, candidates preparing for the NTS GAT can look forward to the official test dates and schedules. This article provides insights into the NTS GAT, its importance, and the 2025 test schedule.


Graduate Assessment Test (GAT)

The Graduate Assessment Test (GAT) conducted by NTS is a standardized examination in Pakistan. It serves as an essential assessment tool for candidates seeking admission into postgraduate programs (M.Phil. and Ph.D.) across various universities. Additionally, organizations utilize the NTS GAT for recruitment, particularly for positions requiring higher educational qualifications.

The GAT evaluates candidates’ aptitude, analytical reasoning, critical thinking, and subject-specific knowledge. This test ensures a transparent and fair evaluation process, helping universities and employers select the most qualified candidates.

Categories of NTS GAT

The NTS GAT is divided into three main categories:

1. GAT-General

This category assesses general aptitude, analytical reasoning, and critical thinking skills. It is designed for candidates applying for M.Phil. programs and job seekers whose employers require GAT-General scores.

Subcategories of GAT-General:

GAT-A: For Arts and Humanities candidates.

GAT-B: For Science and Engineering candidates.

GAT-C: For Agriculture, Veterinary, Biological & Medical Sciences, and Physical Sciences candidates.

GAT-D: For Religious Studies (Madrassa Background) candidates.

2. GAT-Subject

This test evaluates candidates’ knowledge in specific subjects, primarily for Ph.D. admissions. It is available for disciplines including natural sciences, social sciences, engineering, and management sciences. Candidates must choose their relevant subject while registering.


3. GAT-Law

GAT-Law is designed for those seeking admission into LL.M. programs or legal positions that require a GAT-Law score. The test assesses knowledge of legal principles, including constitutional, criminal, and civil law.

NTS GAT General Test Schedule 2025

GAT Test Preparation

Candidates can access GAT test preparation books in print and digital formats. Some recommended books include:

  • Fully Solved NTS New Testing System
  • The Best Book For GAT (General)
  • Dogar’s Unique NTS Guide
  • The Official Guide To Revised GRE General
  • Basic Preposition for GAT
  • GAT Analytical Reasoning

Online Practice Tests

Online practice tests are valuable tools to help candidates assess their strengths and weaknesses before the actual exam. These practice tests cover all sections of the GAT exam, including verbal, quantitative, and analytical reasoning.

GAT Passing Marks

Candidates must obtain at least 50% marks to pass the GAT. Currently, only 38% of candidates meet this passing criterion, which means many applicants must retake the test.

NTS Contact Details

Address: Headquarters (Islamabad Office), 96, Street No. 4, Sector H-8/1, Islamabad.

Phone: +92-51-9258478-79

Fax: +92-51-9258480

Website: www.nts.org.pk

Law Admission Test (LAT) Registration 2025 – Complete Guide

0

Are you worried about your upcoming Law Admission Test (LAT)? Don’t stress! LLBGuide.com is here to guide you through the entire LAT registration process and answer all your questions.

What is the LAT Test?

The Higher Education Commission (HEC) introduced the Law Admission Test (LAT) to ensure that only deserving students enter the law profession. This test is mandatory for students who wish to pursue careers as lawyers, civil judges, or legal consultants.

HEC LAT Test Registration 2025 in Pakistan

If you have recently appeared in the Intermediate Annual Examination and want to pursue LLB, then great news for you! HEC Islamabad has announced the LAT Test Registration 2025.

Eligibility Criteria for LAT Registration 2025

  • Must have completed Intermediate (FA/FSc/ICom or equivalent) from a recognized board.
  • Result-awaiting students can also apply.
  • Apply for Law Admission Test (LAT) till 16 MARCH 2025.

Students must apply online through the etc.hec.gov.pk  before the deadline. HEC will not extend the registration date, so make sure to apply on time.

LAT Test Date 2025

Currently, HEC has not announced the official LAT test date 2025. However, once the date is confirmed, it will be updated on LLBGuide.com. Keep visiting for the latest updates.

LAT Online Registration Process 2025

The government has made it compulsory for students to pass the LAT Test before applying to any law college in Pakistan. Follow these steps for easy registration:

  1. Visit the official HEC website 
  2. Create an account and complete your profile.
  3. Fill out the LAT application form with accurate details.
  4. Deposit the LAT test fee of Rs. 1820/- through ATM, online banking, or bank draft in Account No: 1742 7900 133401.
  5. Submit the application before 30th October 2025.

Important Details for LAT Applicants

  • Only completed applications will be accepted.
  • Incomplete forms will not be processed.
  • If you face any difficulties, visit the HEC Online Help Center for assistance.

Why is the LAT Test Important?

The Law Admission Test is designed to evaluate students in:

  • Essay Writing (English & Urdu)
  • English Language Skills
  • General Knowledge & Islamic Studies
  • Basic Mathematics
  • Personal Statement (Why do you want to study law?)

Final Words

If you dream of becoming a lawyer, judge, or legal expert, make sure to complete your LAT registration before 16 MARCH 2025. Stay updated with the latest announcements on LLBGuide.com and start preparing for your exam today!

For more details and to apply, visit 

Lat Test Solved Past Papers

0

Preparing for the Law Admission Test (LAT)? Get access to LAT Test Solved Past Papers to boost your chances of success! These past papers provide a comprehensive insight into exam patterns, frequently asked questions, and marking schemes. By practicing with solved papers, you can enhance your essay writing, MCQ-solving skills, and time management. Whether you’re aiming for high scores or just want to familiarize yourself with the test format, these past papers will be your ultimate guide. Start your preparation today and ace the LAT exam with confidence!

Click on the links below to download Past Papers of LAT

To be continue….

“Latest LAT Past Papers | LAT Test MCQs | Law Admission Test Preparation | Updated LAT Practice Questions | Essential LAT Study Material”

LAT Test Syllabus 2025

0

Law Entrance Exam (LAT) is an exam for students who are acknowledge to a five-year LLB program in Pakistan. The exam politic skills such as reading, writing, general knowledge, and calculation and is conducted by the Council of Higher Education (HEC). This article explains the details of LAT 2025 in simple language to help students.

What is the LAT Test?

The LAT exam checks whether students are ready to study law. It measures skills such as reading, writing, general knowledge, and arithmetic. A good LAT score is essential for admission to law schools and universities in Pakistan.

LAT Test Structure

The LAT exam has two parts: objective questions and subjective questions. Here are the details:

1. Objective Section

This section contains Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs) on the following topics:

  • English: (20 points)
  • Vocabulary
  • Grammar Sentences
  • Synonyms and Antonyms
  • General Knowledge: (20 points)
  • Current Affairs
  • Pakistan Studies
  • Basic General Knowledge and Islamic Studies or Ethics: (10 points)
  • Basic Islamic Concepts (Non-Muslim students can answer questions related to ethics.)
  • Pakistan Studies: (10 items)
  • History and Culture of Pakistan
  • Law and Higher Education
  • Mathematics: (10 points)
  • Basic Arithmetic
  • Algebra and Geometry
  • Urdu : ( 10 points )
  • 2.
    • Topics are related to current issues or social themes.
    • Word limit: 200-250 words.
    • Personal Statement: (10 Marks)
    • Students write about why they want to study law.

How to Prepare for the LAT Test 2025

Here are some simple tips to prepare for the LAT:

1. Understand the Syllabus

Learn all the topics mentioned above. Study one subject at a time to stay focused.

2. Practice Past Papers

Solve past papers to understand the exam pattern and improve time management.

3. Improve Writing Skills

Practice essay writing and personal statements. Write clearly and logically.

4. Stay Updated

Read newspapers and watch news to stay informed about current events.

5. Use Good Resources

Study from good preparation books and online materials that cover the LAT syllabus.

Key Details to Remember

  • Eligibility: Students who have completed FA/FSc or equivalent can take the LAT.
  • Test Frequency: LAT is held twice a year.
  • Passing Marks: You need at least 50 out of 100 marks to pass.
  • Validity: The LAT result is valid for two years.

Conclusion

The LAT Test 2025 is the first step toward a legal career in Pakistan. With proper preparation and practice, students can perform well in the test. Start early, stay consistent, and focus on both objective and writing skills.

Good luck to all future lawyers!

HEC LAT 2025: Comprehensive Guide for Law Admission Test in Pakistan

1

The HEC Law Admission Test (LAT) 2025 is a standardized test conducted by the Higher Education Commission (HEC) of Pakistan. It is a mandatory requirement for students seeking admission to undergraduate law programs in public and private universities across the country. This test assesses candidates’ understanding of legal concepts, reasoning skills, and written communication. At LLB Guide, we aim to provide detailed guidance to help you succeed in this important exam.

Table of Contents

  1. Syllabus of the HEC LAT Test
  2. Weightage of Subjects
  3. Duration of the Test in Pakistan
  4. Eligibility for the HEC Law Admission Test
  5. Frequency of the LAT Exam
  6. Online Registration Process
  7. Preparation Tips
  8. How to Prepare for the LAT
  9. Conclusion
  10. Additional Professional Writing Tips

Syllabus of the HEC LAT 2025 Test

The test is divided into two main sections

Part I: Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs)

This section consists of 75 MCQs covering the following subjects:

  • English
  • General Knowledge
  • Pakistan Studies
  • Islamiat
  • Mathematics
  • Urdu

Part II: Essay & Personal Statement Writing

This section includes:

  1. Essay Writing: Write an essay on a general topic in up to 200 words (15 marks).
  2. Personal Statement: Write about yourself in up to 200 words (10 marks).

Both the essay and personal statement can be written in either English or Urdu.

Weightage of Subjects in HEC LAT 2025

The subject-wise weightage for the LAT is as follows:

  • English: 20 marks
  • General Knowledge: 20 marks
  • Pakistan Studies: 10 marks
  • Islamiat: 10 marks
  • Mathematics: 5 marks
  • Urdu: 10 marks
  • Essay: 15 marks
  • Personal Statement: 10 marks

To pass the LAT, students must score at least 50 out of 100 marks.

Duration of the HEC LAT 2025 Test in Pakistan

The total duration of the LAT is 2 hours and 20 minutes:

  • Part I (MCQs): 100 minutes
  • Part II (Essay & Personal Statement): 40 minutes

Eligibility for the HEC Law Admission Test

Students must meet the following criteria to be eligible for the LAT:

  • Completed Higher Secondary School Certificate (HSSC) or an equivalent qualification.
  • Students who have appeared in the final HSSC exam or equivalent but are awaiting results.

Any changes to the exam schedule will be updated on the HEC’s official website: http://etc.hec.gov.pk.

Frequency of the LAT Exam

The LAT is conducted by HEC three or more times a year, typically in October, December, March. The next Apply for Law Admission Test (LAT) till 16 MARCH 2025. The exact dates are announced by HEC in advance.

Online Registration Process

To register for the LAT:

  1. Visit http://etc.hec.gov.pk.
  2. Complete the online application form.
  3. Pay the test fee of Rs. 1820 through online banking, ATM, or bank draft.
  4. After successful registration, download your roll number slip from the same portal one week before the test date.

Preparation Tips

  • Familiarize yourself with the syllabus and exam format.
  • Focus on improving your essay writing and personal statement skills.
  • Practice past papers and sample MCQs for better time management.
  • Stay updated on current affairs for the General Knowledge section.
  • Review basic concepts in English, Mathematics, and Pakistan Studies.

How to Prepare for HEC LAT 2025

  1. Study Resources: Use LAT preparation books, online resources, and past papers.
  2. Practice Regularly: Dedicate time daily to practice essays, personal statements, and MCQs.
  3. Mock Tests: Take practice tests to get familiar with the exam pattern.
  4. Time Management: Allocate time for each section during preparation and the test.

Conclusion

The HEC LAT 2025 is a critical step for students aspiring to join law programs in Pakistan. With proper preparation and understanding of the syllabus, you can excel in the test and secure admission to your desired law school. At LLBGuide, we are dedicated to providing you with the best resources and tips to achieve your goals. Stay focused, practice regularly, and ensure timely registration.

Additional Professional Writing Tips

    • Use simple and clear language in your essays.
    • Organize your ideas logically and avoid grammatical errors.
    • Practice writing within the word limit to manage time effectively during the test.

    Good luck with your preparation!

    LAT Test Date 2025 – Updated Schedule

    4

    The LAT Test Date 2025 – Updated Schedule is an important exam for students who want to pursue a five-year LLB program in Pakistan. Conducted by the Higher Education Commission (HEC), this test assesses the aptitude of candidates for legal studies. Below are all the updated details regarding the LAT Test Date 2025 and registration process.

    LAT Test Date 2025 – Key Information

    • Test Date: 5 MARCH 2025
    • Time: Morning Session
    • Location: Designated centers across Pakistan
    • Registration Deadliner 16 MARCH 2025
    • Test Type: Law Admission Test (LAT)

    Make sure to register at etc.hec.gov.pk before the registration deadline.

    How to Register for LAT Test 2025

    To register for the LAT Test 2025, follow these simple steps:

    Step 1: Visit the HEC Registration Portal

    Go to the official HEC website at etc.hec.gov.pk.

    Step 2: Sign Up or Log In

    If you’re a new user, sign up for an account. If you already have an account, log in with your credentials.

    Step 3: Complete Your Profile

    Fill in your personal and educational details as required.

    Step 4: Pay the Registration Fee

    Pay the registration fee through the bank challan provided on the portal.

    Step 5: Upload the Paid Challan

    Upload the scanned copy of your paid challan to complete your registration process.

    Step 6: Download Your Roll Number Slip

    Once registered, download your roll number slip before the test date.

    LAW-GAT Registration – Important Details

    The LAW-GAT (Law Graduate Assessment Test) registration is also open. LAW-GAT is mandatory for law graduates wishing to become advocates in Pakistan.

    • LAW-GAT Registration Deadline: 16 MARCH 2025.
    • LAW-GAT Test Date: 16 MARCH 2025.
    • Register at: etc.hec.gov.pk

    LAT Test Format 2025

    The LAT Test 2025 consists of the following sections:

    Essay Writing (15 Marks)

    You will be required to write an essay in either English or Urdu.

    Personal Statement (10 Marks)

    A brief personal statement will assess your thoughts and writing skills.

    Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs)

    • English Vocabulary and Grammar
    • General Knowledge
    • Pakistan Studies
    • Islamic Studies

    Total Marks: 100
    Passing Marks: 50

    How to Prepare for LAT Test 2025

    Essay Writing Practice

    • Focus on writing clear, well-structured essays on current topics in both English and Urdu.

    MCQs Preparation

    Revise General Knowledge, Pakistan Studies, and Islamic Studies to perform well in the MCQs.

    Take Mock Tests

    Simulate exam conditions by taking mock tests to improve time management and confidence.

    Stay Updated

    Keep an eye on updates from HEC regarding any changes in the exam schedule or registration process.

    Conclusion

    The LAT Test Date 2025 is fast approaching on 5 MARCH 2025. Make sure you complete your registration by the 16 MARCH 2025. deadline. For further details and to register, visit the official HEC website at etc.hec.gov.pk.

    Good luck with your preparations for the LAT Test and LAW-GAT! 🚀

    Asma Jilani Case PLD 1972 SC 139

    0
    Asma Jilani Case

    Asma Jilani Vs. The Government of the Punjab case is a unique and important case in the Constitutional history of Pakistan. In the Asma Jilani case, the Supreme Court of Pakistan declared the first two Martial laws, by General Muhammad Ayub Khan on the 7th of October 1958 and General Yahya Khan on 21 March 1969, illegal.

    Asma Jilani Case

    Asma Jilani Case Notes

    The leading case Asma Jillani Case PLD 1972 SC 139 has been briefly and simply explained below.

    Background

    On 21 March 1969, General Yahya Khan imposed Martial law in the country became the Chief Martial Law Administrator, and abrogated the 1962 Constitution of Pakistan. He also dissolved the National Assemblies and Provincial Assemblies, and he preserved the Courts and existing laws but issued an order known as the “Removal of Doubts Order 1969”.

    In this order, the Chief Martial Law Administrator General Yahya Khan imposed a bar on the jurisdiction of Courts and said that the Courts cannot issue a writ or pass an order that may be against the order or action of the Army Chief or any person under his authority.

    Facts of the Asma Jilani Case

    In the Asma Jillani Case, there were filed two writ petitions in the High Courts against the detentions by General Yahya Khan under Martial Law regulations number 78 of 1971.

    • The first writ petition was filed by Mrs. Asma Jilani in the Punjab High Court, for the release of her father Malik Ghulam Jilani Advocate.
    • The second writ petition was filed by Mrs Zareena Gohar in the Sindh High Court, for the release of her husband Altaf Gohar.

    Both the writ petitions were dismissed by the respective High Courts on the ground that they did not have jurisdiction to allow these writ petitions following the Removal of Doubts Order 1969.

    Appeal in the Supreme Court

    Mrs Asma Jilani appealed the order of the Punjab High Court in the Supreme Court of Pakistan. This appeal was heard by 5 members bench including Chief Justice Mehmood ur Rasheed, Justice Waheed Ud Din Ahmad, Justice Muhammad Yaqoob Ali, Justice Salahuddin Ahmad, and Justice Sajjad Ahmad.

    The prime question of the Asma Jilani case before the Supreme Court was whether the Courts have jurisdiction to pass an order on these writ petitions or not, whether the ‘Removal of Doubts Order 1969’ is a valid order or not, and whether the bar imposed on the jurisdiction of Courts in the ‘Removal of Doubts Order 1969’ is valid or not.

    The second question was whether the judgment given in the Dosso Case was correct or not because the Federal Government was relying on the judgment of the Dosso Case.

    In the Dosso case, Chief Justice Munir validated the Martial law imposed by General Muhammad Ayub Khan, based on Kelsen’s theory.

    Decision of the Supreme Court

    In Asma Jilani Case, the Supreme Court of Pakistan held that:

    • The judgment of the Dosso case given based on Kelsen’s theory was invalid and incorrect because Kelsen’s theory was not universally accepted, we had Objective Resolution, and we had our own Constitution (Constitution of 1956).
    • The Martial law imposed by General Yahya Khan was illegal.
    • So, all the orders and regulations passed in this Martial law were also illegal.
    • The detention of Mr. Malik Ghulam Jilani Advocate and Mr. Altaf Gohar under Martial Law Regulation number 78 of 1971 was also declared illegal and the Court issued the orders for their release.
    • It was also held that the bar on the jurisdiction of Courts can not be imposed.
    • The Supreme Court of Pakistan also directed the President of Pakistan Mr Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto to constitute a constitution for the Country and restore democracy.

    Conclusion

    In the Asma Jilani Case, the Supreme Court of Pakistan courageously declared illegal, the first and the second Martial laws imposed by General Muhammad Ayub Khan and General Yahya Khan respectively. The Supreme Court also gave direction to the President to make a new constitution for the country.

    FAQs

    What is Martial Law Regulation 78?

    Martial law regulation 78 means the Martial Law authorities may detain a person for any length of time without giving him any reasons.

    What is Article 190 of the Constitution of Pakistan?

    Article 190 says that all executive and judicial authorities throughout Pakistan shall act in aid of the Supreme Court.

    Who can remove the Chief Justice of Pakistan?

    The President of Pakistan.

    What is Article 191 of the Constitution of Pakistan?

    Article 191 empowers the Supreme Court and High Court to make rules regulating its practice and procedure.

    Begum Nusrat Bhutto Case

    0
    nusrat bhutto case

    Begum Nusrat Bhutto Case, (Vs Chief of Army Staff) was the second case in which the Supreme Court validated Martial law imposed in the country by the Army officials, based on the “Doctrine of Necessity”.

    nusrat bhutto case

    Begum Nusrat Bhutto Case PLD 1977 SC 657

    The leading constitutional case, the Nusrat Bhutto case pld 1977 sc 657 is explained in simple words.

    Background

    On the 7th of March 1977, there were general elections in the country, and two major parties participated in this election, namely Pakistan Peoples Party and PNA (Pakistan National Alliance). PNA consisted of 9 political parties.

    The Pakistan Peoples Party got 155 seats in this election, on the other side the PNA only got 36 seats. Mr Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto retained his office as the Prime Minister of Pakistan.

    The opposition rejected the election result and made allegations of buncos and interference in the election by Mr. Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto and started the anti-Bhutto Movement against him. As a result of the anti-Bhutto Movement, there have been protests, chaos, and stampeding in the country.

    On the 5th of July 1977, the Chief of Army Staff General Zia Ul Haq promulgated Martial law in the country. He temporarily suspended the Constitution of Pakistan 1973 and dissolved the Federal and Provincial Assemblies. He also appointed the High Court’s Chief Justices as the acting Governors.

    Afterward, on the 17th of September 1977, General Zia Ul Haq detained Mr Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto and ten other leaders of the Pakistan Peoples Party under Martial Law Order number 12.

    Facts of Nusrat Bhutto Case

    The facts of Begum Nusrat Bhutto case are briefly described below.

    Writ in the Supreme Court

    Begum Nusrat Bhutto who was the wife of Mr Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto, filed a writ petition in the Supreme Court of Pakistan under Article 184 (3) of the Constitution of 1973, against the detention of her Husband.

    Advocate Mr Yahya Bakhtiyar represented Begum Nusrat Bhutto.

    Arguments of Yahya Bakhtiyar

    The main arguments of Advocate Mr Yahya Bakhtiyar were:

    • He relied on the Asma Jilani Case (in which the Martial law imposed by General Yahya Khan was declared illegal).
    • He said that in the Constitution of 1973, there was no such power for the Army Chief to impose Martial law in the country.
    • So, the Martial law is illegal and General Zia Ul Haq should be convicted under Article 6 of the Constitution of 1973.
    • He also said that the purpose of such detention is to prevent the Pakistan Peoples Party from the upcoming elections.
    • He argued that even then we consider this Martial law justified, for the sake of argument, such detention of Mr Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto and ten other leaders of Pakistan Peoples Party is still illegal because this detention is based on discrimination and no leaders from any party have been detained.

    Arguments of Respondent

    Advocate Mr A.K Brohi represented General Zia Ul Haq, his arguments were:

    • He relied on the Dosso Case (in which the Supreme Court validated Martial law, imposed by General Muhammad Ayub Khan, based on ‘The Doctrine of Necessity’).
    • He said that there had been chaos and stampeding in the country and the Martial law was necessary to impose.
    • Such Martial law was temporary, there were elections the next month and democracy would be restored in the country.
    • And whereas the Constitution was suspended, the detentions made under this Martial law were also valid.

    Decision of the Supreme Court

    The Supreme Court decided unanimously in the Begum Nusrat Bhutto Case. It was held that:

    • The act of General Zia Ul Haq imposing Martial law was not a Martial law but an extra-constitutional step that was necessary to take because there were so many protests in the country.
    • The Supreme Court once again discussed the Doctrine of Necessity.
    • The act of General Zia Ul Haq was temporary and valid.
    • The writ petition filed by the Begum Nusrat Bhutto was not maintainable and was rejected because the Constitution itself was suspended (for the time being).
    • The detention of Mr Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto was legal.
    • Martial law imposed by General Zia Ul Haq was also legal.

    The Supreme Court also elaborated that the facts of the Asma Jilani case were different, Martial law imposed by General Yahya Khan was unwarranted and unnecessary so was illegal, but here is a completely different scenario.

    Conclusion

    In the Nusrat Bhutto case, the Supreme Court rejected the writ petitions and declared the detention of Mr Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto legal.

    Usif Patel Case

    0
    Usif Patel Case

    Usif Patel case is also a significant case in the constitutional and judicial history of Pakistan. It started after the judgment of the Molvi Tameez ud Din case when 46 laws passed by the Constituent Assembly without the assent of the Governor General became invalid by the effect of Judgment and there arose legal crises in the country.

    usif patel case

    Usif Patel Case Vs Crown PLD 1955 SC 387

    Usif Patel vs Crown case or Usif Patel case has been explained below in very simple words.

    Background

    The very complicated background of the Usif Patel Case has been mentioned below:

    In the Judgment of Molvi Tameez Ud Din case, when the Federal Court struck down section 223A of the Government of India Act 1935 because it was passed by the Constituent Assembly without the assent of the Governor General, a broader principle also settled that all laws passed by the Constituent Assembly without the assent of Governer General are invalid and ultra-virus.

    By the effect of the Judgment of the Molvi Tameez Ud Din case, 46 laws that were passed by the Constituent Assembly without the assent of the Governor General also became invalid and there arose constitutional and legal crises in the country because in these 46 laws, there were some laws which changed the composition and power of Constituent Assembly and Provincial Assemblies.

    To overcome this catastrophic situation Governor General Ghulam Muhammad issued an ordinance named “Emergency Powers Ordinance 1955”. In this ordinance, Governor General Ghulam Muhammad did these things:

    • He gave his assent to all 46 laws with retrospective effect.
    • He invested himself with the power to frame the Constitution.
    • He may authenticate the budget of the Central Government.
    • He declared the West Pakistan as a province.
    • He changed the name of East Bengal to East Pakistan.

    Under section 9 of the Indian Independence Act 1948, the Governor General may add any provision to the interim Constitution, till 31 March 1948.

    The Constituent Assembly extended such authority of the Governor General till 31 March 1949 by the “Indian Independence Amendment Act 1948” (on 19 March 1948 without the assent of the Governor General).

    The Governor General added section 92(A) in the Government of India Act 1935 by which he authorized the Provincial Governors to make laws for the concerned province if necessary (on 26 July 1948).

    In 1952 the Governor of Sindh passed an act named as “Sindh Control of Gundas Act 1952”.

    According to this law, the Government may based on doubt direct any person to furnish security that he will not breach the law or get involved in any illegal activity and if such person refuses to furnish security he may be detained.

    Facts of Usif Patel Case

    District Magistrate Larkana detained and confined three people namely Usif Patel, Agha Muhammad, and Syed Ali Shah because they refused to give surety following the Sindh Control of Gundas Act 1952.

    Writ in Chief Sindh Court

    Usif Patel and his friends moved the writ petition after the decision of the District Magistrate in the Chief Sindh Court, under section 491 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

    The Chief Sindh Court held that:

    • Their confinement is legal.
    • And dismissed their petitions.

    Appeal in Federal Court

    Usif Patel and his friends appealed the decision of the Chief Sindh Court in the Federal Court of Pakistan and challenged the validity of the “Sindh Control of Gundas Act 1952”.

    Arguments by Petitioner

    The petitioners mainly argued that:

    • The “Indian Independence Amendment Act 1948” passed by the Constituent Assembly had no assent of the Governor-General,
    • So by the effect of the judgment of the Molvi Tameez Ud Din Case, the Indian Independence Amendment Act 1948 is invalid,
    • So the Section 92A is invalid,
    • So the “Sindh Control of Gundas Act 1952” is invalid,
    • So their detention is also invalid.

    Arguments by Respondent

    In Usif Patel case, the Advocate General argued that:

    • The Governor General by the “Emergency Powers Ordinance 1955” has given his assent to all 46 laws with retrospective effect,
    • So the “Indian Independence Amendment Act of 1948” became valid,
    • So Section 92A,
    • So the “Sindh Control of Gundas Act 1952” is valid.

    Decision of Federal Court

    In Yousaf Patel Case, there were two main questions before the Federal Court of Pakistan, that were:

    • Whether the Governor General by an ordinance validate the Indian Independence Act 1948? and,
    • Whether the Governor-General may give assent to Constitutional legislation by the Constituent Assembly with retrospective effect?

    The Federal Court decided that:

    • The Governor General had no authority to act under section 92A of the Indian Independence Act 1948 which was added by amendment without assent.
    • So no power has been transferred to the Provincial Governor for legislation.
    • Accordingly the “Sindh Control of Gundas Act 1952” is ultra virus.
    • The detention of appealants is illegal.
    • The Governor General can not give assent with retrospective effect.
    • Government of India Act 1935 and Indian Independence Act 1948 are constitutional and the Governor General is incompetent to validate them by ordinance.

    The Federal Court also elaborated the fact that the Governor General had no power to frame the Constitution, only the Constituent Assembly had such power, which was dissolved.

    Conclusion

    Like Molvi Tameez Ud Din Case, Chief Justice Muhammad Munir in Yusuf Patel Case once again passed the judgment on the fact that all laws passed by the Constituent Assembly without the assent of the Governor General are invalid.